That is how Linux grows, folks.Īnyway, because Android does not use all of the ALSA/MIDI infrastructure, these non class compliant devices remain unsupported in Android unless the quirks are rewritten in Java. Upon receiving the listing, a developer (usually Clemens Ladisch) adds the corresponding quirks to the table and after successful testing the next release of Linux shall work with the device. This command provides detailed information about of the USB descriptors of the plugged devices. Most of the time, when a new device is not supported by Linux, users ask to the ALSA project for support, in which case they are requested to run a simple command after the device is plugged: For other devices, here is the quirks table ("In a perfect world, this file would be empty."): The standard USB-MIDI protocol was supported from day one. It has been happening to the ALSA USB driver that many devices (non class compliant) require special "quirks" to make them work in Linux. I have one and when I use it I see the following behaviourġ) The apps from only work with this Midi adaptor if it is switched to Tablet modeĢ) Other apps like "USB Midi Monitor" work no matter what the switch is set toģ) This 2nd type of app requires me to grant USB access permission which I do not need for the type 1) aboveġ) why has the industry come up with the need to have a switch on these devices? what problem is it solving?Ģ) what if I get a digital piano with no switch, which of the 2 behaviours will I get? and I much prefer the API of rather than some direct USB accessģ) can the Android / Linux kernel do something so that it works in both cases? This device has the usual type-A USB connector which plugs into a computer port.įor an Android tablet I need an adapter which I believe is called USB-OTG adapter. I have used it for a while in Desktop mode and it works very well in Linux and is immediately recognised by ALSA and I have been using in Jackd via a2jmidi. This device had a switch Tablet / Desktop mode The USB Midi adaptor I have is a Roland UM-ONE mk2. I think I wasn't very precise and I would like you to help me understand the situation of MIDI on Android.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |